Harry Scarborough
| Date | H/A | Opponent | Competition | KO/Score | Attd | Scorers |
|---|
| Sat 26 Aug | A | Gainsborough Trinity | NPL Premier | (0)1 - 1(0) | 452 | Scarborough |
| Mon 28 Aug | H | Workington AFC | NPL Premier | (3)3 - 0(0) | 615 | Scarborough, Benns, Rigg (og) |
| Sat 23 Sep | H | Morpeth Town | NPL Premier | (2)3 - 3(3) | 378 | Forbes, Baxter, Scarborough |
| Tue 26 Sep | A | Atherton Collieries | NPL Premier | (0)2 - 1(1) | 226 | Wilson (pen), Scarborough |
| Sat 11 Nov | H | Basford United | NPL Premier | (1)5 - 2(0) | 470 | Scarborough, Billington, Edwards (2), Bayode |
| Sat 23 Dec | A | Bradford (Park Avenue) | NPL Premier | (0)3 - 0(0) | 300 | Scarborough, Bould, Bange |
| Sat 3 Feb | A | Macclesfield | NPL Premier | (0)1 - 2(1) | 3,005 | Scarborough |
| Tue 20 Feb | A | Lancaster City | Lancashire Trophy QF | (3)7 - 4(3) | 232 | Edwards, Scarborough (2), Churchman, Cullen (3) |
| Sat 24 Feb | A | Worksop Town | NPL Premier | (1)4 - 2(1) | 629 | Leigh, Edwards, Dodd, Scarborough |
| Tue 12 Mar | H | Atherton Collieries | NPL Premier | (1)3 - 1(1) | 288 | Scarborough, Churchman, Baxter |
| Wed 20 Mar | H | Southport | LFA Challenge Trophy 2023/24 SF | (0)3 - 1(1) | | Scarborough, Leigh, Wilson |
| Mon 1 Apr | A | Lancaster City | NPL Premier | (1)2 - 3(2) | 414 | Scarborough, Potts |
| Tue 23 Apr | H | Macclesfield | NPL Premier | (1)2 - 1(1) | 538 | Adubofour, Scarborough |
