| 1 | Sat 3 Feb | A | Macclesfield | NPL Premier | (0)1 - 2(1) | 3,005 | Scarborough |
| 2 | Sat 10 Feb | A | Morpeth Town | NPL Premier | (1)3 - 1(1) | 436 | Edwards, Leigh, Baxter |
| 3 | Tue 20 Feb | A | Lancaster City | Lancashire Trophy QF | (3)7 - 4(3) | 232 | Edwards, Scarborough (2), Churchman, Cullen (3) |
| 4 | Sat 24 Feb | A | Worksop Town | NPL Premier | (1)4 - 2(1) | 629 | Leigh, Edwards, Dodd, Scarborough |
| 5 | Tue 12 Mar | H | Atherton Collieries | NPL Premier | (1)3 - 1(1) | 288 | Scarborough, Churchman, Baxter |
| 6 | Sat 16 Mar | A | Warrington Rylands | NPL Premier | (0)0 - 2(0) | 411 | |
| 7 | Wed 20 Mar | H | Southport | LFA Challenge Trophy 2023/24 SF | (0)3 - 1(1) | | Scarborough, Leigh, Wilson |
| 8 | Sat 23 Mar | H | Stafford Rangers | NPL Premier | (0)0 - 2(0) | 527 | |
| 9 | Sat 30 Mar | H | Gainsborough Trinity | NPL Premier | (1)1 - 3(1) | 537 | Baxter |
| 10 | Mon 1 Apr | A | Lancaster City | NPL Premier | (1)2 - 3(2) | 414 | Scarborough, Potts |
| 11 | Sat 6 Apr | H | Ashton United | NPL Premier | (1)1 - 3(0) | 443 | Doumbouya |
| 12 | Sat 13 Apr | A | FC United of Manchester | NPL Premier | (0)0 - 3(1) | 1,501 | |
| 13 | Tue 16 Apr | H | Ilkeston Town | NPL Premier | (0)1 - 4(0) | 192 | Wilson (pen) |
| 14 | Sat 20 Apr | H | Whitby Town | NPL Premier | (1)3 - 2(2) | 472 | Leigh (2), Grand |
| 15 | Tue 23 Apr | H | Macclesfield | NPL Premier | (1)2 - 1(1) | 538 | Adubofour, Scarborough |
| 16 | Sat 27 Apr | A | Basford United | NPL Premier | (0)0 - 4(1) | 427 | |
| 17 | Tue 30 Apr | H | Colne | Lancashire FA Challenge Trophy 2023/24 F | (2)2 - 5(0) | | Potts, Bould |
